Southport Reporter ® Online Newspaper for Merseyside
Southport and Mersey Reporter- Your online only weekly Newspaper.
Your Online Newspaper for the Merseyside Area.

Click on to see our Twitter Feed.  Click on to see our Facebook Page.   






Updated news stories weekly.  Published online only.

Your online newspaper.   Your words.

Issue:- Thursday, 13 October 2016

Headlines and reports on this page = 2 news items.    Page - 9.

Tax experts call for new penalties to target deliberate promotion of avoidance rather than commercial advice

Tax experts are warning that Government proposals to penalise 'enablers' of Tax avoidance schemes are too widely drawn and could result in some taxpayers and businesses being unable to get expert advice on complicated and often unclear areas.

The Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) is concerned that this could impact on, among other matters, investment into the UK. The CIOT said the penalties should be better targeted at those who deliberately seek to profit from Tax avoidance.

HMRC is proposing a significant new penalty for those who 'enable' Tax avoidance and profit from doing so, and also a change to the existing penalty legislation which applies to those who use avoidance which is exposed and defeated by the Tax Authority.

The CIOT fears the proposals and definition of enablers is so widely drawn that it will catch many ordinary business services, for example company formation agents, just because some avoidance schemes rely on setting up companies.

It could also penalise advisers who give perfectly reasonable and legitimate advice to clients, including on inward investment into the UK. Many reputable advisers may be deterred from advising on complex matters on the grounds they may be seen as 'enabling avoidance' and this would severely tarnish their reputation, irrespective of penalties.

Assuming the proposal is properly targeted, the penalties need to be large enough to deter the behaviour the Government is seeking to stop, but should not topple over into retribution; in a democratic society, sanctions need to be proportionate and measured, otherwise the legal system itself can be brought into disrepute.

The CIOT has welcomed HMRC's broad consultation on the changes and has set out its views in its response to the Government's 'Strengthening Tax Avoidance Sanctions and Deterrents' discussion paper.

John Cullinane, CIOT's Tax Policy Director, said:- "The Government needs to be careful that in its effort to wipe out avoidance schemes it does not prevent taxpayers from getting access to honest, impartial advice on the law. If the Government wants to incentivise good behaviour and penalise bad, as we think it should, the proposals should target the deliberate behaviour of the small persistent minority who devise and market avoidance schemes. It should not interfere with the right of taxpayers to obtain full and rounded advice on complex and often unclear areas of law. It could be calamitous for businesses and other taxpayers if Tax advisers (or their insurers) feel too anxious about the new sanctions to help them sensibly plan their Tax affairs within the law and avoid these taxpayers laying themselves open to large, unintended Tax bills. It is vital to our economy that the proposals are properly focussed, otherwise they risk making the UK, a much less attractive place for commercial transactions. If the proposals catch the services needed by inward investors; as well as existing taxpayers; ranging from company incorporation to advice on highly complex legislation, this would be a real deterrent to investing in the UK. Given that the UK is the European base for many investments, this would be very damaging to the UK economy. We recognise that there are limited financial penalties at present for those who devise and actively market Tax avoidance schemes but the tax-geared penalty being proposed is draconian. It should be related to the fees or commission received by the enabler. Anything else would be disproportionate."

The Institute has recommended in its response that the term 'enabler' should be defined in terms of those who devise and play an active role in the promotion of Tax avoidance schemes by requiring a stronger and more positive link between the financial benefits sought and the Tax avoidance.

The Tax experts suggest that there should be a defence for professional advisers who are members of a regulated body or a body with professional rules that address the issue of Tax avoidance.

The Institute has also recommended to the Government that any final proposal should apply to enabling that takes place only after the date that it comes into force. John Cullinane said:- "We look forward to continuing to work with HMRC to produce a workable outcome."

So what do you our readers think about this? Please do let us know your views by emailing us to:- and let us know what you think should be done!

News Report Page Quick Flick.

Click on here to go back to this week's home page! News Report Page Quick Flick
Click on this section to see last weeks edition of Southport and Mersey Reporter!

Sign up today for our daily email news service!

Sign up to our Daily Email News Service by clicking here now...

Did you know we where the UK's 1st online only newspaper and we still are?  Here at Southport and Mersey Reporter  we are still at  leading the way for local news.

All email addresses and information is held under the UK's Data Protection Act.




Deceased estates notice - Lilian May Jackam

Pursuant to the Trustee Act 1925, any persons having a claim against or an interest in the Estate of Lilian May Jackam (also known as Lillian May) Jackam (Deceased), late of Birch Abbey Rest Home, 55 Alexandra Road, Southport, Merseyside, PR9 9HD, UK, who died on 04/10/2018, are required to send particulars thereof in writing, to the undersigned Solicitors, on or before 24/05/2019, after which date the Estate will be distributed having regard only to claims and interests of which they have had notice. Churches Solicitors, 12 High Street, Fareham, Hampshire, PO16 7BL, UK. Ref:- 'T553015.'

..Paid Advert..

Contact us:-
(+44)  08443 244 195
Calls will cost 7p per minute, plus your telephone company's access charge.
Calls to this number may be recorded for security, broadcast, training and record keeping.

RSS  Weekly Headline Update Notices
4a Post Office Ave, Southport, Merseyside, PR9 0US, UK
This online newspaper and information service is regulated by IMPRESS, the independent monitor for the UK's press.

This online newspaper and information service is regulated by IMPRESS the independent monitor for the UK's press.

How to make a complaint

This is our process:-  Complaints Policy  -  Complaints Procedure  -  Whistle Blowing Policy


See the view live webcamera images of the road outside our studio/newsroom in the hart of Southport.

Our live Southport Webcam image above.
To see it live, please click on image.

Event Notices

More events that are taking place on Merseyside can be found on our Event Listings Calendar.

Find out whats on in and around Merseyside! Click on here to see our event calendar.
Are you going to this event?  If you are please let us know what you thought of it!

These are our other websites within the Southport & Mersey Reporter Network.

Mersey Reporter - OUR HUB WEBSITE. Liverpool Reporter - Our online music station. Southport TV - Our online video archive.
Mersey Reporter Formby Reporter Liverpool Reporter Southport TV


Tracking & Cookie Usage Policy - Terms & Conditions

© - Southport Reporter® is the Registered Trade Mark of Patrick Trollope